quolira quolira.com

Surely, comrades, you do not want Jones back?

39 / 1448

Who said it?

George Orwell said it, in Animal Farm, Chapter 5.

Squealer turns a question about debate into a question about the old tyrant, and the animals have no answer. It is a neat trick, and he uses it repeatedly.

From the collection: 19 Animal Farm Quotes on Power, Propaganda, and Betrayal · More George Orwell quotes

About this quote

Meaning

The quote asks the other animals whether they truly want to bring back the former human owner, and it expects a firm no as the answer. It is a rhetorical question meant to end debate by appealing to a shared fear of returning to the old way of life.

Context

The line comes from the fifth chapter of Animal Farm, when the animals are reminded of the dangers of human rule and the hardships they escaped. The question works as a tool for the leadership, because it frames any criticism of current policy as a step toward restoring the farmer. Orwell uses this technique to show how fear of an external enemy can be used to keep the population compliant. Readers see that the threat of Jones is invoked again and again, even as the pigs take on many of the same habits the humans once had.

About the author

George Orwell (1903 to 1950) was an English novelist, critic, and essayist. He published Animal Farm in 1945, and the book is widely regarded as a satire of how revolutions can be betrayed by their leaders. Orwell's wider body of work, including Nineteen Eighty-Four, examines fear, loyalty, and the manipulation of public opinion. His writing is valued for its plain style and its sharp attention to the ways political language can shape what people are willing to accept.

Frequently asked questions

Who said "Surely, comrades, you do not want Jones back?"?
George Orwell said it, in Animal Farm, Chapter 5.
What does "Surely, comrades, you do not want Jones back?" mean?
The quote asks the other animals whether they truly want to bring back the former human owner, and it expects a firm no as the answer.
Up next

“Discipline, comrades, iron discipline! That is the watchword for today.”

George Orwell · Animal Farm, Chapter 5

“Four legs good, two legs bad!”

George Orwell · Animal Farm, Chapter 3

“Yet he is lord of all the animals. He sets them to work, he gives back to them the bare minimum that will prevent them from starving, and the rest he keeps for himself.”

George Orwell · Animal Farm, Chapter 1

“Only get rid of Man, and the produce of our labour would be our own.”

George Orwell · Animal Farm, Chapter 1

“Is it not crystal clear, then, comrades, that all the evils of this life of ours spring from the tyranny of human beings?”

George Orwell · Animal Farm, Chapter 1

“Things are lovelier because they will not last.”

Original

“Ikigai is less a thing you find and more a thing you keep doing.”

Original

“If what I see in my mind excites me, there is a good chance it will make a good photograph.”

Ansel Adams

“I would never apologize for photographing rocks. Rocks can be very beautiful.”

Ansel Adams

“It is horrifying that we have to fight our own Government to save the environment.”

Ansel Adams

“I eagerly await new concepts and processes. I believe that the electronic image will be the next major advance.”

Ansel Adams · The Negative (1981), introduction to second edition

“For me the future of the image is going to be in electronic form.”

Ansel Adams · Interview with Paul Hill (March 1975), published in Dialogue with Photography (1979)